Home › How We Rate
Rating methodologyComparePetCover scores US pet insurance companies on a transparent, weighted set of criteria. This page explains what we measure, where our data comes from, and the guardrails that keep our ratings independent.
Who rates, and why you can verify it
Our reviews are researched and written by Yassine Dekkak, founder and editor of ComparePetCover. We are an independent analyst, not an insurer, a licensed agent or a veterinarian, and we base every score on published policy documents and public data you can look up yourself. Where a fact drives a score, we want it to be checkable.
Our rating criteria
Each provider earns a score out of 5 built from five weighted criteria. Coverage breadth and value for money carry the most weight because they decide what you actually get for what you pay.
| Criterion | Weight | What we check |
|---|---|---|
| Coverage breadth | 25% | Accident, illness, hereditary/congenital, dental, behavioral, and exam fees: how much of real-world veterinary care the plan can actually reimburse. |
| Value for money | 25% | Premium measured against the real reimbursement you would receive after the deductible and reimbursement rate are applied, not the sticker price alone. |
| Claims experience | 20% | How quickly and reliably claims are paid, based on each insurer's published claims process and payout terms (for example direct vet payment and stated processing times). |
| Limits & flexibility | 15% | Annual payout cap, deductible type (annual vs per-condition), and how far the plan can be customized to your budget and pet. |
| Transparency | 15% | How clearly the provider spells out waiting periods, exclusions (including pre-existing conditions), and price increases at renewal. |
| Total | 100% | Weighted into a single score out of 5. |
Where our data comes from
Our scores are only as good as the sources behind them, so we keep those sources public and consistent. For every provider we draw on:
- The insurer's public policy documents. Sample policies, benefit schedules, and terms of coverage are our primary source for what is and isn't covered, waiting periods, and exclusions.
- How we handle prices. We do not collect live quotes. State cost figures are modeled averages (NAPHIA's national average premium adjusted with BEA Regional Price Parities), and prices mentioned for individual insurers are indicative and change often, so always get your own quote.
We're honest about the limits of this: pet insurance pricing is highly individual, and public information isn't equally detailed for every provider. Where a source is thin, we say what we relied on rather than implying more precision than we have.
How to read our scores
Every provider score is expressed out of 5. Here's what each band means:
Broad coverage and strong value, with few meaningful trade-offs.
A solid, competitive plan with minor gaps or higher pricing in places.
Workable for some owners, but clearly bettered by rivals on key criteria.
Notable weaknesses in coverage, value, claims, or transparency.
How often we update
Pet insurance changes: prices move, coverage terms get rewritten, and providers add or drop benefits. We update on a rolling basis rather than once a year, and we re-score a provider whenever coverage, price, or claims information changes in a way that matters. You'll see a visible last-updated date on every provider review and state page so you always know how current the information is.
Our limits (in the interest of transparency)
ComparePetCover provides general educational information only. ComparePetCover's editor is an independent analyst, not a licensed insurance agent, financial advisor, or veterinarian, and nothing here is personalized advice. Our ratings are a research-based starting point, not a recommendation for your specific pet or situation. Always confirm coverage details, prices, and terms directly with the provider before you buy, and for licensed guidance in your state you can start with the NAIC and your state department of insurance.
Frequently asked questions
Is ComparePetCover paid by insurers to rank them higher?
No. No insurer can pay for a higher score, a badge, or placement. We may earn a fixed referral fee when a reader requests a quote through a partner link, at no extra cost to you, whether or not they buy. That payment never changes a score or the order of providers in a table. Scores come only from our weighted criteria.
How often are ratings updated?
On a rolling basis. We recheck policy terms and the price sources we cite throughout the year and update a provider's score whenever coverage, price, or claims information materially changes. Every review and state page shows a visible last-updated date.
Where do your price figures come from?
We do not collect live quotes. State cost figures are modeled averages built from NAPHIA's national average premium and BEA Regional Price Parities, and prices mentioned for individual insurers are indicative. Your own quote depends on your pet, breed, age, ZIP code and plan.
Who writes the reviews?
Reviews are researched and written by Yassine Dekkak, founder and editor of ComparePetCover. ComparePetCover's editor is an independent analyst, not a licensed insurance agent or veterinarian.